I love the dimensions of this song. The layers are what stand out most to me as I listen, especially as the song progresses. There’s a funky reverb that builds to a nice cushion under Styles’ voice. I’ve noticed that that level of richness is often missing from pop music these days; listen to the radio and the blurry synths start to run together. Even though “American Girls” uses a drum machine, the beat stretches and envelops Styles’ voice without overwhelming it. I get major ’70s vibes, which is also fun; most pop songs reach for ’80s synth influences.
The lyrics themselves are less to write home about; they’re a cute musing about the temptations and frustrations of, well, American girls. It’s unclear whether Styles wants these girls or is skeptical of relationships with them, but either way, he can’t help noticing how enthralling they are.